Word of advice from a consultant for professional development for college faculty - IndiaBioscience


#1

To be appointed as a school teacher in India, a diploma or graduation in education is a must. This ensures some familiarity with pedagogy. Contrast this to faculty candidates at higher levels, who are selected based mainly on content knowledge. Consequently, knowledge and/or experience of teaching methodology is either limited or entirely absent.

Throughout my professional career as an educator, I have consistently sought to think not only about what is being taught, but also how it is taught. Determined to do more than criticise the system, I chose to become a consultant to teaching faculty. In this capacity, I work with teachers, either individually or in groups. At other times, my services are hired by an entire school/department/institute. Whatever the situation, the process requires me to gather background information and customise my advice based on that; it also matters whether the advice is sought for short- or long-term. I work with teachers to identify lacunae, we mutually agree on goals as I guide them towards solutions. Though there are a few concepts common to most cases, I consider each person/situation uniquely. I outline below some of the avenues available for professional growth of undergraduate faculty in India, and share my advice as a freelance consultant.

What does Professional Development involve?

Broadly, professional development includes tracking and documenting of skills, knowledge and experience that teachers gain beyond any initial training (formally and informally). In addition to ‘learning on the job’, it is both necessary and possible to seek expert help in teaching well. The experts may be more experienced and/or effective colleagues, content specialists or advisors in pedagogy. The National Curriculum Framework of Teacher Education (NCFTE, 2009) states a number of aims of ‘Continued Professional Development’ for Indian teachers. They range from ‘exploring, reflecting and developing one’s own practice’ to ‘researching and reflecting on learners and their education’, and ‘breaking out of intellectual isolation and sharing experiences and insights with others in the field, both teachers and academics working in the area of specific disciplines as well as intellectuals in the immediate and wider society’.

Everyone is familiar with the orientation programmes for new faculty offered by academic staff colleges; but these are mainly catered to university faculty. A main drawback of these programmes is that they are too generic and therefore vague. Funding agencies like the UGC and DBT or faculty associations at various levels also organise workshops for faculty. The options I have listed here are of more customisable nature, catering to needs of individual faculty or college/institute.

Professional development for college faculty: ‘why’ and ‘how’ to do it?

Usually, only schools are monitored by Education departments. We do not hear of inspectors visiting college classrooms to assess activities and progress. I am not advocating the need for such supervision but an internal, self-motivated system of feedback set up by the faculty for themselves would go a long way in improving teaching practices in colleges.

Reflecting on one’s own teaching practices, maintaining a journal of self-appraisal, is the simplest yet most effective mode of professional development. To aid in this self-analysis, one’s apprehensions as well as achievements as teachers can be discussed with students, seniors and colleagues resulting in instant feedback. Subscribing to and reflecting on the content of relevant magazines and blogs can also be very useful. Examples include articles in journals as Active Learning in Higher Education, Journal of research in science teaching.

Online platforms like the national knowledge network and Google groups such as ‘Teach in India’, can be utilised to carry out discussions with like-minded faculty. These forums provide opportunities to discuss with colleagues, contribute articles to these sources can greatly help faculty in their professional growth as teachers.

Interested faculty can also sign-up for online courses offered by EdX and Edutopia, for instance, often allowing the learners to proceed at their own pace. The benefits would multiply if several members of the faculty register for the courses together and gain from discussing the content and performing the activities together.

Colleges can also avail services of consultants (some freelance, others work as adjunct faculty) to advice on improving teaching practices. I would like to close with a couple of my experiences as a reflective practitioner teaching at the undergraduate level:

> In a course on organismal biology, focusing mainly on ecology and evolution, the students were asked to write one of their assignments as a journalistic report. In consultation with science writers and non-biologists, I prepared a marking chart considering weightage to be given to various aspects of the report like the title, content, style etc. In one batch, unexpectedly, a student decided to add a very relevant photograph to the report, which really enhanced the assignment. This led me to rethink my chart – I had to add a column for images. So, in addition to taking the help of experts in other fields, work of a student also enabled me to plan the evaluation/feedback better.

> As a resource person, I met Biology faculty from different universities at a workshop on laboratory techniques of conducting experiments with fruit-flies. In the four-day workshop, some of the participants who worked with fruit-flies for the first time, realised how simple and low-maintenance the flies were. This experience assured them of being able to grow stocks of flies in their respective laboratories and several of them discussed clear contexts and lab sessions they planned for their students using different aspects of flies at various stages of their life cycle. Presenting the ideas to their peers from other places provided them with insightful advice which helped to make the plans more practical and effective.

As an undergraduate faculty, if you would like to discuss options for your own professional development, I would be very interested to hear from you.

Further Reading:

https://teachingcommons.stanford.edu/teaching-talk

***********

(The author has been a researcher in biology and an educator, formerly a faculty at the undergraduate programme of IISc; now freelancing as an independent advisor to academic institutes and teaching faculty.)


This is a companion discussion topic for the original entry at https://indiabioscience.org/columns/opinion/word-of-advice-from-a-consultant-for-professional-development-for-college-faculty

#2

This article brings out a very important point. Teaching profession also needs to be learnt and mastered. While the country has some kind of teachers’ trainng programme for school teachers, there are hardly any such avenues for college and university teachers. All the courses conducted by the Academic Staff Colleges and the various workshops organized by different institutions for college and university teachers are primarily aimed to provide ‘new information’ to teachers rather than also engage them in methods of conveying the information.Obviously, as Dr. Yermal points out, what is taught is important, but how it is taught is more important. The common belief and practice that providing new and ‘latest’ information in the classroom makes for ‘good teaching’ is indeed misplaced. I also believe that the recent creation of ‘smart classrooms’ by itself does not improve teaching. It may , and often it does, actually do more damage if the powerpoint presentation is just run through the class without any discussion. In such a situation, why should students be stitting in the class - they may as well get a copy of the ppt file!!

The point is well made that we need to mentor and train teachers in good teaching methods, which can and would vary in different disciplines and contexts. Teachers need to continue learning not only new developments but also better methods to communicate the new developments in proper context.


#3

Thanks Prof.Lakhotia for your expert opinion. It is very relevant that you pointed out “The common belief and practice that providing new and ‘latest’ information in the classroom makes for ‘good teaching’ is indeed misplaced.”

Regarding use of powerpoint, or use of any such technology in teaching for that matter, can be effective only if the teacher understands how it can serve a clear purpose, instead of using it as a novelty. For this to happen, the best talented youth must willingly take up teaching - I do hope a mechanism of attracting such teachers be in place soon!


#4

Dear Sir,
Thanks for your contribution. I have few questions:

  1. If we want to become a consultant, whether we need an official certificate?
  2. What is the qualification for that?
  3. How we will approach school or colleges for that? Any agency to help that?

Currently I am working as a scientist after completing my Ph.D and postdoctoral fellowship